Finding a crayon eyeliner pencil that glides on without tugging, delivers intense pigment, and stays put through a long day is the real challenge. Too many formulas either skip across the lid or fade into a smudged mess by lunchtime, leaving you frustrated and reaching for a makeup wipe.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind WellFizz. I’ve spent countless hours analyzing customer experiences and formula specifications across dozens of eyeliners to find the ones that actually perform.
This guide cuts through the hype to deliver a curated selection of top performers. You’ll find my picks for the best crayon eyeliner pencil based on real user feedback and technical specs that matter.
How To Choose The Best Crayon Eyeliner Pencil
The crayon eyeliner pencil is a staple for quick, defined looks, but formulas vary wildly in texture, staying power, and application ease. Understanding what separates a good pencil from a great one will save you time and irritation.
Gel vs. Traditional Wax Formulas
Gel-based crayon eyeliners offer a creamy, pigmented glide that sets into a smudge-resistant finish. Traditional wax-based pencils are often drier, requiring more pressure and causing tugging on the delicate eye area. For the smoothest application and longest wear, look for gel or cream formulas.
Waterproof and Transfer-Resistant Claims
True waterproof performance is critical for all-day wear, especially on the waterline where moisture is constant. Check customer reviews specifically mentioning “waterline” and “waterproof” to verify a brand’s claim. Transfer-resistant formulas prevent the liner from migrating to the crease or under-eye area, avoiding the dreaded raccoon eyes.
Pigment Intensity and Buildability
High-density pigment allows for a bold, one-swipe line, while buildable formulas let you create softer, more natural looks. If you need deep black or rich brown, prioritize pencils with “intense” or “high-impact” in their description. A pencil that requires multiple passes can feel chalky and smear during application.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Too Faced Killer Liner | Premium Gel Pencil | All-day waterline wear | 36-hour waterproof gel formula | Amazon |
| Tarte Fake Awake | Brightening Pencil | Opening and brightening eyes | Nude brightening shade with built-in smudger | Amazon |
| Tarte Double Take | 2-in-1 Pencil & Pen | Versatile day-to-night looks | Coal tip one end, felt tip the other | Amazon |
| Trish McEvoy Intense Gel | High-End Gel Pencil | Sweat-proof, high-impact definition | Creamy waterproof gel with built-in sponge | Amazon |
| NYX Epic Ink Liner | Felt Tip Pen | Precise, fine winged liner | Ultra-precise brush tip with quick-dry formula | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil
Too Faced’s Killer Liner claims a 36-hour wear time, and while that number may be aspirational, the performance is genuinely remarkable. The gel formula glides onto the waterline and lash line with zero skipping, delivering a rich, opaque line in a single pass. Customers consistently praise its ability to resist smudging, weeping, and flaking — even by the end of a long day, there is no raccoon eye effect.
The pencil is available in deep shades like Midnight Black and Espresso, both offering fantastic pigmentation. A key point for waterline users: this formula truly stays put where many other pencils fade. Removing it requires a dedicated makeup remover rather than soap and water, which confirms its durability. The pencil is also sharp, meaning you’ll need a sharpener, but the pay off in staying power makes it worthwhile.
Keep in mind that the pencil is on the shorter side, and the included sharpener can be finicky — many users recommend investing in a quality dual-blade sharpener for best results. Despite these minor quirks, the Too Faced Killer Liner is a top performer for anyone who demands a smudge-proof, all-day eye look.
Why it’s great
- Glides on smoothly without tugging
- Truly waterproof and smudge-proof even on the waterline
- Intense pigment payoff with one swipe
Good to know
- Pencil is short and may not last as long as expected
- Requires a good sharpener for precise application
2. Tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight
The Tarte Fake Awake is not your standard liner — it is a brightening pencil designed to open up the eyes. Its nude, peachy-beige shade is perfect for the waterline, inner corners, and brow bone, instantly neutralizing redness and creating a more awake appearance. The formula is creamy and glides without pulling, a common issue with cheaper brightening pencils.
User reviews highlight its lasting power, with many saying it stays on the waterline for the majority of the day without migrating. The built-in smudger on the end is a clever addition for blending out the color for a softer, more natural highlight. It’s also vegan, cruelty-free, and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
One trade-off is that it is not a classic liner — its purpose is brightening, not defining. The shade range is limited to this one natural nude, so it won’t serve as your all-purpose dark liner. If you frequently use white or nude pencils on your waterline, this is a high-quality upgrade that truly delivers on its promise of looking well-rested.
Why it’s great
- Creamy, non-tugging application for the waterline
- Natural brightening effect that neutralizes redness
- Built-in smudger for blending
Good to know
- Only available in one nude shade
- Not a dark liner for defining the lash line
3. Tarte Double Take Eyeliner
For those who can’t decide between a pencil and a liquid pen, the Tarte Double Take offers both in one sleek package. One end features a traditional crayon pencil (which you can sharpen) for a smudgeable, gel-like line, while the other end is a fine-tipped felt liquid pen for precise, sharp wings. This dual-ended design covers virtually every eyeliner look you could want.
The pencil side delivers a semi-matte, lightweight finish that can be smudged for a softer look, while the liquid side offers a crisp, intense black line that dries down quickly. Customers report that both sides last through the day without smudging or flaking, and the formula is gentle enough for those with sensitive eyes.
A common criticism is that each side does not last as long as dedicated single products would — the product can run out quicker than you might like, especially if you use both ends daily. Also, while the pencil side is good, it is not as intensely waterproof as some other dedicated gel pencils on this list. It is a fantastic travel-friendly option, though, for its convenience and versatility.
Why it’s great
- Two-in-one design covers pencil and liquid liner needs
- Smooth, lightweight formula on both ends
- Great for creating both smudged and precise looks
Good to know
- Each end may run out faster than a single product
- Pencil side is not fully water-resistant
4. Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner
The Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner is a professional-grade pencil that has been a cult favorite for years. Its creamy, high-density pigment formula delivers an opaque, rich line without requiring any pressure. The built-in sponge smudger on the back end is incredibly useful for blending out the line into a smoky eye or softening the look on the lower lash line.
Performance-wise, this liner is remarkably resilient. Customer feedback from active users — including those who wear it through high-intensity workouts and sweaty days — confirms that it stays put without running or fading. The Aubergine shade is frequently cited as a perfect complement to green and hazel eyes, and the pencil lasts for months with daily use.
The main downside is the premium price point, which positions it as an investment piece. Also, the built-in smudger sponge can sometimes arrive loose or detach from the cap, which is a minor but frustrating quality control issue. For those who prioritize a smooth, long-lasting, and blendable gel liner, however, the Trish McEvoy delivers unmatched performance.
Why it’s great
- Exceptionally creamy, no-tug formula
- Survives sweat, humidity, and long days
- Built-in sponge makes smudging easy
Good to know
- Premium pricing may not suit all budgets
- Smudger sponge can detach from the cap
5. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
While technically a felt-tip liquid pen rather than a crayon pencil, the NYX Epic Ink Liner is too popular and well-reviewed to ignore as a budget-friendly alternative for precise lining. Its ultra-fine brush tip allows for incredible precision, making it a favorite for creating sharp, crisp winged liners with ease. The formula is waterproof, quick-drying, and deeply pigmented.
Customers repeatedly call this liner their “holy grail” because of its performance-to-price ratio. The liquid flows consistently without drying out on the tip, and the black shade is a true, deep black. It is also vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with clean beauty standards. Many users find it easier to control than a pencil for creating fine, flicked tails.
There are a couple of considerations. The bristles on the tip can loosen or fray over time, especially if stored tip-down. Also, because it is a liquid, it requires a steady hand and a moment to dry, unlike a pencil which offers more immediate smudge-ability. For those focused on precision and value, however, the NYX Epic Ink Liner is a standout choice.
Why it’s great
- Ultra-precise brush tip for fine lines and wings
- Fast-drying, waterproof, and deeply pigmented
- Excellent value for the quality
Good to know
- Brush tip can fray over time
- Liquid formula requires a steady hand and drying time
FAQ
How do I sharpen a gel eyeliner pencil without breaking it?
Can a crayon eyeliner pencil be used on the waterline?
How can I make my pencil eyeliner last all day?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best crayon eyeliner pencil winner is the Too Faced Killer Liner because it delivers unbeatable staying power on the waterline, glides on smoothly, and resists smudging like no other. If you want a brightening effect and a wide-awake look, grab the Tarte Fake Awake. And for a versatile, travel-friendly two-in-one solution, nothing beats the Tarte Double Take.
Mo Maruf
I created WellFizz to bridge the gap between vague wellness advice and actionable solutions. My mission is simple: to decode the research and give you practical tools you can actually use.
Beyond the data, I am a passionate traveler. I believe that stepping away from the screen to explore new environments is essential for mental clarity and physical vitality.