Our readers keep the lights on and my smoothie glass nicely filled. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
You do not have to choose between harsh steroids and endless itching. Coal tar creams are a decades-old, non-prescription way to calm angry, scaly skin. The catch is the strong smell, greasy feel, and overwhelming number of choices. This guide cuts through the noise to show you which coal tar cream is worth buying and why.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind WellFizz. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
You will find a fast-acting lotion for full-body flare-ups and a precise gel for stubborn scalp patches. Each of these four picks targets a different stage of skin recovery, so you can match the treatment to your exact need.
Our Picks at a Glance
How To Choose The Best Coal Tar Cream For Eczema
Coal tar slows rapid skin-cell growth that causes plaques and scales, while reducing inflammation and itch. The best choice depends on where flare-ups occur, how thick and stubborn the patches are, and how much you care about the smell.
Concentration and Formula Type
Most over-the-counter creams use a 2% coal tar solution. A higher concentration, like the 7.5% LCD (liquor carbonis distillate) found in Cutar Emulsion, is considered more potent and is often the go-to for thick, longstanding plaques. But higher potency can also mean a stronger odor and more staining, so match the strength to the severity of your skin.
Texture: Cream vs. Lotion vs. Gel
A thick cream is best for dry, cracked patches on your body — it stays put and seals in moisture. A lotion spreads easily over large areas like your arms or legs but can feel runny. A gel is specifically designed for the scalp and other hairy spots, giving you targeted application without dripping into your eyes or down your neck.
The Smell Factor (It is Real)
Coal tar creams smell like, well, tar. Some formulas use essential oils to mask the odor, and some people find the smell fades quickly after application. If you are sensitive to scents, look for a formula where owners specifically note the smell is manageable or fades fast — otherwise you might struggle to use it daily.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Formulation | Size | Active Ingredient | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Blaine’s RevitaDERM Psoriasis Treatment 4 oz (Pack of 3)★ Best Overall | Daily whole-body maintenance | Cream | 4 oz per bottle (Pack of 3) | 2% Coal Tar | Amazon |
| Salve Cosalic Gel | Precise scalp application | Gel | 3.38 fl oz | Coal Tar & Essential Oils | Amazon |
| Cutar Emulsion Cream | Fast relief for thick plaques | Lotion / Emulsion | 5.92 oz | 7.5% LCD Coal Tar | Amazon |
| Cutar Emulsion 6 oz (Pack of 2) | Long-term supply for severe cases | Liquid Emulsion | 6 oz per bottle (Pack of 2) | Coal Tar Solution | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Dr. Blaine’s RevitaDERM Psoriasis Treatment 4 oz (Pack of 3)
Our pick — 4.5★ from 100+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
The three-bottle bundle that makes daily treatment a no-brainer for the whole family.
This is the pick that wins on pure practicality. It contains 2% coal tar as the active ingredient, and the company promises you will see improvement in just days. The three-pack means you can keep one in the bathroom, one in a travel bag (each pack comes with a travel-size bottle for on-the-go use), and one as a backup — so you never run out mid-flare-up. Buyers report it “really helps my son with his psoriasis,” which speaks to how gentle enough it is for regular use on sensitive skin.
The biggest trade-off is the smell — coal tar has a distinct odor, and some owners find it strong enough to mix in perfume drops to mask it. At 1.57 pounds for the three-bottle set, it is noticeably heavier than the Cutar Emulsion single bottle, but you get 57% more product by weight per pack compared to buying three separate bottles of the Cutar alternative. If you need a reliable, everyday cream for large areas, this bundle is the most logical place to start.
What Families Love
- Three-bottle pack with a travel-size included eliminates rationing
- 2% coal tar is the standard effective OTC strength
- Owners mention it clears stubborn patches where other creams failed
The Realistic Downsides
- The coal tar smell is noticeable — some owners add scent drops to make it more pleasant
- A few users with undiagnosed skin conditions needed to try it for a while before seeing results
The three-bottle solution: Reach for this if you manage chronic eczema or psoriasis across large areas and want a steady supply without repurchasing every few weeks.
Think twice if: You are extremely sensitive to strong smells — you may want to test a single bottle first or try the Cutar Emulsion instead.
2. Salve Cosalic Gel (100 ml / 3.38 fl oz) with Coal Tar & Essential Oils
The leave-on gel that lets you target scalp patches without the mess of a cream.
If your eczema or psoriasis lives on your scalp, behind your ears, or along your hairline, a thick cream is the wrong tool. This gel is designed precisely for those spots — it has a concentrated gel formula that does not drip, so you can apply a small amount directly to the flaky area, massage it in, and leave it on. The owner experiences back this up: one buyer bought it after running out of a prescription steroid cream and found it “worked just as good,” which is about the highest praise a non-prescription product can get.
At 4.59 ounces (compared to the Cutar Emulsion Cream single bottle at 5.92 ounces), but you are paying for precision, not volume. The essential oils help cut the heavy coal tar smell, though it is still present — some owners find storing it in the refrigerator helps. For anyone who has struggled to smear lotion into their scalp without it running into their eyes, this gel solves a real problem.
Gel precision wins: The no-drip texture is the standout feature — it stays exactly where you put it, making it ideal for the scalp and hairline without wasting product.
The one-note caution: The smell is still there (coal tar is coal tar), and effectiveness varies by person — a few owners found it only average for their specific flare-ups.
Perfect for scalp-only flare-ups: Get this if you need targeted relief for flaky, itchy scalp patches and want a product that behaves like a gel, not a runny lotion.
Skip it for: Full-body application — at 3.38 fl oz, you would run through a bottle too fast on arms and legs.
3. Cutar Emulsion Cream – Coal Tar Lotion for Relief from Eczema, Psoriasis, and Dermatitis
The heavy-hitting emulsion that customers note calms angry skin within a single day.
This is the cream buyers mention with real urgency in their reviews. It uses a 7.5% LCD (liquor carbonis distillate — a refined coal tar extract) base, which is far stronger than the standard 2% you find in most drugstore creams. Multiple reviewers point out that it “helped my psoriasis within a day.” The formula is designed to penetrate deeper than surface-level creams, so it softens plaque buildup and stops flakes from forming, not just soothes the top layer.
The texture is a liquid emulsion — think a runny lotion, not a thick paste — which makes it easy to spread over large areas like arms, legs, and your back. You can even add it to a bath for a full-body soak. The catch is the smell: it is noticeable, with some owners comparing it to working on cars, though others say the odor fades quickly. Skin relief is the thing owners praise most, with over 70 people calling it out, and the soothing effect is the second most-discussed benefit. For thick, stubborn plaques that laugh at weaker creams, this is the right next step.
Why Buyers Rely on It
- 7.5% LCD coal tar is more potent than typical 2% OTC creams — works on tough, longstanding plaques
- Non-greasy formula dries down quickly compared to many psoriasis treatments
- Can be used as a topical cream or added to bath water for whole-body relief
The Honest Trade-Offs
- Liquid consistency can be messy if you squeeze too hard — tap it onto your finger instead
- The coal tar smell is real and divisive — some find it mild and fading, others dislike it strongly
For tough, stubborn skin: Choose this if you have thick plaques or persistent patches that have not responded to regular 2% coal tar creams.
Not for the smell-sensitive: If you are bothered by odors, test a small amount first — the stronger concentration brings a stronger scent.
4. Cutar Emulsion 6 oz (Pack of 2)
The two-bottle pack for anyone who has found their holy grail and just needs more of it.
This is the same Cutar Emulsion formula — a coal tar solution in a liquid emulsion texture — but in a two-bottle set that gives you 12 total fluid ounces. Each bottle holds 6 oz, which is roughly 177 mL, and the liquid spreads evenly across the skin. Owners who swear by it describe it as a “great lotion to help heal atopic dermatitis overnight” and say daily use keeps flare-ups under control and dries up active patches. A few buyers even call it the “perfect solution for psoriasis” when other products failed.
The downside is purely practical: the plastic bottles do not have a seal under the cap, and a few deliveries have arrived with slight leakage. It is a minor packaging complaint about an otherwise excellent product, and the value of getting two 6-ounce bottles is obvious for anyone who already knows this formula works. At 1 pound total for the pair, it is lighter than the Dr. Blaine’s 3-pack, but you get more liquid volume per bottle compared to the single 5.92 oz Cutar option — making this the right choice for heavy daily users who want to reduce repurchase frequency.
Best for confirmed believers: If you have already used the single Cutar Emulsion bottle and it worked for you, this two-pack saves you from ordering again in a few weeks.
The one annoyance: No inner seal on the bottle means a small risk of leakage in transit — it is a packaging oversight, not a product flaw.
Grab this if: You use Cutar Emulsion daily or have multiple family members who need it, and you want a longer supply without repurchasing as often.
Stick with the single bottle if: You are trying coal tar for the first time — test the 5.92 oz single before committing to the larger two-pack.
Understanding the Specs
Coal Tar Concentration
This is the most important number on the label. Most over-the-counter creams use a 2% coal tar solution, which is effective for mild to moderate eczema and psoriasis. A product labeled with 7.5% LCD — that is liquor carbonis distillate, a purified form of coal tar — is more potent and is typically used for thicker, more stubborn plaques. A higher concentration generally works faster and penetrates deeper, but it also tends to have a stronger odor and more staining potential, so match the strength to your skin’s severity.
Cream vs. Lotion vs. Gel
The texture determines how and where you use it. A thick cream stays put on dry, cracked patches and is great for knees, elbows, and hands. A lotion or liquid emulsion spreads easily over large areas like your arms, legs, or torso and can even be added to a bath. A gel is the clear winner for the scalp and hairline — it stays where you apply it without dripping, letting you target small, precise areas behind your ears or along your part line without mess.
FAQ
Is coal tar cream safe to use every day?
Does coal tar cream stain clothes and bedding?
How long does it take for coal tar cream to work on eczema?
Can I use coal tar cream on my face or sensitive areas?
What is the difference between coal tar and steroid creams?
Does coal tar cream have a strong smell?
Can I use coal tar cream if I have sensitive skin?
How should I store coal tar cream?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For the majority of shoppers, the best coal tar cream for eczema is the Dr. Blaine’s RevitaDERM Psoriasis Treatment 3-Pack because it gives you the standard 2% coal tar strength in a practical, cost-effective bundle that you can scatter across your home and bag. If you need stronger medicine for thick plaques that do not budge, the Cutar Emulsion Cream with its 7.5% LCD concentration is your best bet. And if your scalp is the main battleground, the Salve Cosalic Gel delivers precise, no-drip application that no lotion can match.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, WellFizz earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.
Related Guides
Mo Maruf
I created WellFizz to bridge the gap between vague wellness advice and actionable solutions. My mission is simple: to decode the research and give you practical tools you can actually use.
Beyond the data, I am a passionate traveler. I believe that stepping away from the screen to explore new environments is essential for mental clarity and physical vitality.