6 Best Chocolates Online | Skip the Sad Supermarket Box

Check Price on Amazon

The mint lover’s repeat-buy that arrives fresh every time.

Each Mint Meltaway candy wraps a creamy mint chocolate center in a pastel shell or milk chocolate coating, making it a cool and creamy treat that owners mention “melts in the mouth with just the right amount of mint.” At 11.5 oz, it is a mid-size box that customers note buying “several times, and they are always fresh” — a strong sign of consistent quality from a brand that Chicago natives remember from the old Fanny Farmer days.

Unlike the larger Russell Stover assortment at 32 oz versus 12.11 oz for the Fannie May box, the Fannie May box is a focused single-variety gift. Reviewers point out the price tag feels fair for the quality, though a few question the value. It ships in a 11.75 x 7.75 x 8.25 inch box, bigger than the Harry & David truffles, so factor in the packaging size if you are mailing it.

Buyers also mention these make excellent Easter basket stuffers and Valentine’s gifts — the pastel coating and mint flavor are a seasonal hit. The only real trade-off: you get one flavor here, not an assortment, so skip it if you need variety in one box.

Check Price on Amazon

Three iconic Ferrero flavors in one thin box that travels well.

The Ferrero Collection packs the hazelnut milk chocolate Ferrero Rocher, creamy coconut Raffaello, and rich dark chocolate Rondnoir into a single 48-count box. At 1.14 pounds total, each piece is a small, individually wrapped bite — perfect for grazing over days. Reviewers describe the trio as “fresh, well-balanced, not overly sweet” and note that the coconut Raffaello is a standout flavor. One buyer who ordered for a Valentine’s treat said the chocolates arrived undamaged and not melted, even in a thin 12.21 x 1.58 x 10.63 inch box.

Compared to the Ferrero Rocher 42-count box (which is all hazelnut milk chocolate), this collection gives you more flavor variety in the same slim profile. The Ferrero Collection has 48 pieces versus the Godiva Gold’s 60 pieces, but the Ferrero pieces are smaller and lighter — you are paying for variety, not bulk. Shoppers say the elegant gift packaging makes it a solid choice for Easter baskets or dinner parties.

One caution: a few reviewers felt the price was on the higher side unless bought on discount. Another mentioned that the ice packs in the shipment were partially melted, though the chocolates were in perfect condition. If you want a single-flavor powerhouse (all hazelnut), the 42-count Ferrero Rocher box below is a better match.

Check Price on Amazon

Six dark chocolate truffle flavors for the person who skips milk chocolate entirely.

Harry & David’s 8 oz gift box packs six truffle flavors — including a standout lime coconut truffle and a French vanilla truffle — all in dark chocolate. The box is small at 4.49 x 3.66 x 3.54 inches, making it the most compact option here. Reviewers call these truffles “decadent, large, creamy, melt-in-mouth” and one buyer ordered them for Father’s Day after a Mother’s Day success, though that second shipment arrived melted and misshapen — a reminder that dark chocolate can be more sensitive to heat than milk chocolate.

At 8 oz, this box is lighter than the Russell Stover 32 oz option and lighter than the Fannie May’s 12.11 oz. The trade-off is clear: you get fewer pieces, but each truffle is described as large and premium. One reviewer who loved the first purchase said they will not reorder after the melted second shipment, so consider ordering during cooler months or paying for expedited shipping if it is hot.

The flavor lineup is more creative than most boxes — that lime coconut combination is unusual and gets specific praise. If you are shopping for a dark chocolate purist who appreciates nuance over quantity, this is the best niche pick on the list.

Check Price on Amazon

The hazelnut milk chocolate icon that almost everyone loves.

Ferrero Rocher needs no introduction — each piece wraps a single hazelnut in creamy chocolate-hazelnut filling, then coats it in milk chocolate with crispy wafer and roasted hazelnut pieces. The 42-count box weighs 1.68 pounds, which is heavier than the Ferrero Collection’s 1.14 pounds but lighter than the Russell Stover 2-pound box. Buyers call it “a holiday favorite” with “great taste, quality with every bite” and one reviewer specifically noted the long expiration date and the ability to store them in the fridge for a perfect texture — “not sticky but not hard.”

Compared to the Ferrero Collection (which includes coconut and dark), this box is all hazelnut milk chocolate — a single, consistent flavor that works for large groups where you don’t know individual preferences. Reviewers mention keeping them in a dish for guests, only to end up eating them all. The box dimensions are the same as the Collection box (12.21 x 1.58 x 10.63 inches), so it fits the same slim gifting profile.

The main downside is the lack of variety — if you want dark chocolate or coconut, you need the Collection box instead. Otherwise, this is the most universally crowd-pleasing option here, and buyers consistently say the price is a “great value” for what you get.

Check Price on Amazon

A 2-pound assortment with 14 flavors for the biggest gift box here.

Russell Stover’s 32 oz box (2 pounds) is the heavyweight of this list — at 56 pieces across 14 flavors, it includes both milk and dark chocolate enrobed candies with fillings like caramel, maple cream, and the returning Roman Nougat that one reviewer called “the standout.” The box measures 2 x 12 x 6 inches, while the Ferrero boxes measure 12.21 x 1.58 x 10.63 inches. Buyers report that it shipped cold with ice packs and arrived fresh with “no stale pieces” — a key advantage for a box this size, which might sit on a counter for a while.

Compared to the Fannie May box, this gives you 32 oz versus 12.11 oz. One reviewer who bought the 3 lb version noted the “delicious variety, especially caramels and maple cream,” though another flagged that the cost and freshness were “suspect.” The general consensus, however, is that the box is a crowd-pleaser for large gatherings.

If you are filling a gift basket or feeding a crowd, this is the most economical choice. The trade-off is that individual pieces are not as premium as Godiva or Harry & David — these are classic American chocolates, not Belgian artisan pieces.

Check Price on Amazon

A 60-piece Belgian assortment in a keepsake gold box that screams “special occasion.”

Godiva’s Gold Collection houses 60 individually crafted chocolates with fillings like smooth ganache, buttery caramel, bright fruits, and nutty pralinés, all wrapped in milk, dark, and white chocolate. The box weighs 1.54 pounds (24.6 oz) and measures 2.63 x 12.56 x 9.09 inches. Reviewers consistently praise the packaging — “packaged with ice and in Styrofoam” to survive 90°F days — and the box itself is described as a “premium keepsake” with gold satin shimmer and embossed details. One buyer who gifted it to a friend said “she said it was all delicious.”

Compared to the Russell Stover’s 2-pound box, the Godiva is slightly lighter in weight (1.54 lb vs 2 lb) but has 60 pieces versus 56 — meaning smaller, more intricate pieces. Owners mention “these chocolates are all little masterpieces” and “good value for money” given the quality. The Godiva box has 60 pieces versus the Ferrero Collection’s 48 pieces, but the Godiva pieces are denser and more varied in texture.

The biggest trade-off is the price — this is the most expensive box on the list, and it is clearly positioned as a milestone gift (birthdays, anniversaries, Mother’s Day). If you just want a personal stash, the smaller Ferrero or Fannie May boxes make more sense. But if you need a gift that impresses the moment it is opened, the Godiva Gold box does that better than anything else here.