Our readers keep the lights on and my smoothie glass nicely filled. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
Choosing a wedding favor is the last big guest-experience detail before the big day, and chocolate is nearly always the crowd favorite — but the wrong choice can feel like a cheap afterthought instead of a genuine thank-you. The real decision depends on if you want a personalized monogrammed piece that doubles as a place-setting accent or a bulk bag of classic mints and almonds your guests can snack on at the reception or take home. Below are five top-rated options, compared on actual weight, count, and real buyer feedback so you pick the one that fits your table and your budget.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind WellFizz. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Everything you need to decide on the right chocolate wedding favors for your table setting, guest count, and overall theme is laid out below in a straight head-to-head comparison of the five most popular choices available right now.
How To Choose The Best Chocolate Wedding Favors
The best wedding favor is one your guests actually enjoy eating (or take home as a keepsake) — not something that sits on the table untouched. Here is what matters most when narrowing down your choice.
Weight and Count vs Your Guest List
The most common mistake is buying by the bag without checking the per-guest yield. A 13-ounce bag of buttermints holds around 100 mints — enough for 50 guests if you place two per favor box. A 1-pound bag of Jordan almonds also yields about 100 pieces. If you have 150 guests, you need either a bigger bag or two bags.
Personalized vs Bulk Non-Branded
Personalized chocolates (like the Set of 50 with your names and date on each wrapper) double as a decorative place-card or escort-card anchor — but you pay a premium for that custom work, and each piece is much smaller than a typical candy. Bulk buttermints or Jordan almonds give you more edible value per dollar and work better on a candy buffet table where guests grab a handful.
Shipping Conditions and Shelf Life
Chocolate and summer heat are a risky combination. Buyers report that the personalized chocolates arrived unmelted in July because the seller included a thermal wrap and ice pack. For M&M’S or mints, which tolerate heat much better, standard shipping is usually fine. Always check the estimated shelf life — the personalized chocolate is good for up to a year but tastes best within three months of purchase.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Weight | Piece Count | Type | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jordan Almonds Candy 1 lb | Candy buffet / gifts | 16.0 oz | ~100 | Candy-coated almond | Amazon |
| Candy Envy Mr. & Mrs. Buttermints | Individually wrapped favors | 13.0 oz | ~100 | Buttermint | Amazon |
| Gift Boutique Wedding Buttermints | Elegant wrapped mint favor | 13.0 oz | 100 | Buttermint | Amazon |
| Set of 50 Personalized Chocolate | Personalized table favor | 0.0154 lb per piece | 50 | Custom chocolate | Amazon |
| M&M’S Miss to Mrs. 30 Pack | Bridal shower / bachelorette | 1.5 lbs total | 30 (0.75 oz each) | Printed M&M’S | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Set of 50 Personalized Wedding Chocolate
The place-setting favor that says your guest’s name before they even sit down.
This set works as both a favor and a table marker because you put your names and wedding date on every 1.57-inch square wrapper. Each chocolate square weighs 0.0154 pounds — noticeably lighter than the bulk mints or almonds — but that fits its job: visual impact on the plate. Owners mention the chocolates arrived unmelted in July thanks to the seller’s thermal wrap and ice pack, and one reviewer called them “gorgeous,” saying they “added to the elegance.” The chocolate lasts up to one year, though the maker recommends eating it within three months for the best taste.
The trade-off: you get 50 pieces versus 100 in the bulk options like the Jordan Almonds, so the personalization costs more per piece. If your guest list exceeds 50, you need two sets. One reviewer noted the squares were smaller than expected — these are thin chocolates, not a heavy candy bar.
Tabletop Impact
- Custom imprint with your names and date creates a keepsake
- Survived July shipping thanks to thermal wrap and ice pack per buyer reports
- Elegant wrapper design blends with any color scheme
Know Before You Buy
- Only 50 pieces — need two sets for 100+ guests
- Smaller square size than some expect (1.57 x 1.57 inches)
- Best eaten within 3 months for peak flavor
Your move: Pick this if you want a favor that pulls double duty as a place setting and a take-home thank-you, and your guest list is around 50.
Heads-up: For a larger wedding group, you will need to budget for multiple sets, and the thin chocolate is more about presentation than a heavy candy portion.
2. Jordan Almonds Candy — 1 Pound Pack
The classic pastel almond that has been a wedding staple for generations.
At 16 ounces (a full pound) with roughly 100 pieces per bag, these Jordan almonds give you the most edible weight of any pick here — 16 ounces versus 13 ounces for the Candy Envy mints and 13 ounces for the Gift Boutique buttermints. Each almond is roasted and coated in a thin, crisp candy shell. Customers note the “candy shell is thin and easy to chew” and that the almonds arrived “fresh and crisp, all whole, none broken.” The pastel colors (pink, yellow, green, lavender, white) fit weddings, spring parties, and baby showers alike.
A few buyers noted some batches had a very hard coating that did not soften even after sucking on it for half an hour. That experience is not universal — most reviews call them fresh and delicious — but it is note if you are serving older guests or anyone with dental concerns. These are less formal than the personalized chocolates; they work better for a candy buffet or favor bag than as a place-setting anchor.
Bulk coverage: One pound bag gives you about 100 pieces — enough to fill a favor box for every guest at a 100-person wedding, or to top off a candy buffet table with generous handfuls.
Texture watch: Most buyers love the thin shell, but a small number found the coating exceptionally hard; sample one before ordering in bulk for a large event.
Reach for this if: You want a classic, inexpensive favor that fills up a candy buffet or favor bag with real weight and a nostalgic look.
Look elsewhere if: You need a formal, personalized place-setting favor, or you are worried about a few guests struggling with a hard candy shell.
3. Candy Envy — Modern Mr. and Mrs. Buttermints
A sleek mint wrapper that matches a black-and-white wedding scheme perfectly.
Each mint in this 13-ounce bag wears a wrapper printed with “Mr. and Mrs.” — no other text, just the couple motif in a clean, modern font. One buyer confirmed they were “perfect for my daughter’s wedding with a black and white color scheme” and that the taste was good — a bonus, since many favor mints are all wrapper and no flavor. The bag holds approximately 100 individually wrapped mints, so you get the same per-guest count as the Jordan almonds but in a more formal, table-ready format. Compared to the Gift Boutique buttermints, these come in at 13 ounces, and the Gift Boutique buttermints are also listed at 13 ounces.
The main consideration is that “Mr. and Mrs.” wording is best suited for a traditional couple; if you are planning a modern or gender-neutral wedding, the phrase might feel dated. Also, the mints are not buttermints in the creamy sense — they have a cleaner mint flavor, less buttery melt. If you specifically want that melt-in-your-mouth butter texture, the Gift Boutique version below is closer to what you are after.
Why It Works
- Clean “Mr. and Mrs.” print works beautifully on dark tablecloths
- Full 100-count per bag — enough for 50 guests at 2 mints each
- Buyers confirm good taste, not just a pretty wrapper
Why It Might Not
- Traditional wording does not suit every couple’s style
- More of a standard mint than a rich buttermint
Best for: A traditional wedding with a specific color scheme (black and white) where you want a favor that looks like it belongs on the table, not just dumped in a bowl.
skip it if: You want a true buttermint with a soft, buttery texture, or your wedding theme is anything other than a classic Mr. and Mrs. format.
4. Gift Boutique Wedding Buttermints — Love Is Sweet
The buttermint that actually tastes like a buttermint, wrapped in an elegant “Love Is Sweet” wrapper.
This bag delivers the classic wedding-mint experience: a soft, creamy buttermint texture that melts on your tongue, not a hard mint that you have to crunch. The wrapper says “Love Is Sweet” in a clean, elegant print — one buyer mentioned “each individually wrapped mint appears expensive as the printing on the wrappers is even and elegant.” At 13 ounces, it matches the Candy Envy bag at 13 ounces. The bag holds 100 individually wrapped mints, the same count as the Candy Envy version, but with a more classic buttery flavor profile.
The trade-off is that some buyers found these taste more like a “mellow mint” than a true buttermint, missing that buttery note. If you grew up eating soft wedding mints from a candy shop, these are close but not identical. They also come in a standard bag, not a decorative box, so you will want to transfer them to a favor box or display bowl for the reception table.
Texture advantage: These are softer and creamier than the Candy Envy mints, matching the traditional buttermint feel most people expect at a wedding.
Bag vs box: Packaged in a plain bag; you will need your own favor containers or bowls for table presentation.
Choose this if: You specifically want the soft, buttery melt of a classic wedding mint, and you are fine providing your own display containers.
Pass if: You need a favor that looks table-ready straight out of the package, or you prefer a sharper mint flavor over a creamy one.
5. M&M’S WORLD Miss to Mrs. Themed Packs — 30 Pack
The printed M&M’S that turn a favor box into a photo-worthy detail.
Each of the 30 packs holds a 0.75-ounce serving of M&M’S printed with “Bride to Be” and “She Said Yes” on the candies — a playful twist for a bachelorette party, bridal shower, or wedding favor box. The total weight is 1.5 pounds across all 30 packs, which is similar in heft to the Jordan almonds, but the per-guest amount is smaller. Reviewers point out these added “the needed extra touch and detail” for favor boxes and held up well during shipping all the way to South Africa without melting. The official M&M’S brand name gives them built-in recognition — guests know exactly what they are getting.
The biggest downside is the count: 30 packs is tight for a wedding of 50 or more, and at this price point the per-pack cost is higher than buying bulk candies and assembling your own favors. Some buyers also mention mixing these with plain white M&M’S to stretch them further because the printed ones are “pricey to get only the detailed ones.” The packaging is a plain box, not individual favor boxes, so you still need your own containers or bags for each guest.
Why Guests Love Them
- Printed M&M’S are instantly recognizable and fun to eat
- Survived international shipping according to real buyer reports
- Pink, cream, and white color palette matches wedding decor
The Fine Print
- Only 30 packs — covers fewer guests than the other bulk options
- High per-pack cost; buyers often mix with plain M&M’S to save money
- No individual favor containers included — you supply your own
Grab this for: A smaller bachelorette party, bridal shower, or a close-group wedding favor where you want that custom M&M’S print to be the centerpiece.
Skip if: You need to cover more than 30 guests or want the lowest per-person cost — in that case, the Jordan almonds or buttermints offer way more servings.
Understanding the Specs
Weight vs Count
The total weight of a bag (in ounces) tells you how much edible product you get, but the count (how many individual pieces) matters more for planning per-guest favors. Buttermint bags around 13 ounces hold roughly 100 mints — enough for 50 guests at 2 mints each if you fill favor boxes. Jordan almonds at 16 ounces also yield about 100 almonds. If you want a bigger serving per guest, go heavier per bag.
Wrapper Personalization
Custom wrappers add a keepsake element — guests can take home a chocolate with your names and date on it. Buttermints with “Mr. and Mrs.” or “Love Is Sweet” print are pre-printed, not custom, so you cannot change the text. Personalized chocolates (like the Set of 50) let you design the wrapper yourself, but each piece is much smaller (0.0154 pounds vs a typical mint that weighs roughly 0.13 ounces each). Decide if you want the wrapper to be the star or the candy itself.
FAQ
How many chocolate wedding favors do I need per guest?
Will chocolate wedding favors melt during shipping or at the venue?
Can I customize buttermint wrappers with my own names and date?
How long do chocolate wedding favors stay fresh?
Are Jordan almonds the same as chocolate wedding favors?
Which option is best for a candy buffet table?
Do I need to provide my own favor boxes or containers?
What is the difference between buttermints and pillow mints?
Can I use chocolate wedding favors as place cards?
Which chocolate wedding favor is best for a 100-person wedding?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most people, the best chocolate wedding favors winner is the Set of 50 Personalized Wedding Chocolate because it gives you a custom keepsake with your names and date on each wrapper, doubling as a place-setting accent. If you want a bulk option that feeds a candy buffet with real edible weight, grab the Jordan Almonds 1 Pound Pack. And for a traditional wrapped mint with a classic buttery melt that fits a 100-guest reception, the Gift Boutique Wedding Buttermints checks every box.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, WellFizz earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.
Mo Maruf
I created WellFizz to bridge the gap between vague wellness advice and actionable solutions. My mission is simple: to decode the research and give you practical tools you can actually use.
Beyond the data, I am a passionate traveler. I believe that stepping away from the screen to explore new environments is essential for mental clarity and physical vitality.