7 Best Cheese Making Kit | Your First Batch, No Guesswork

Check Price on Amazon

The Food Network winner that takes you from mozzarella to aged cheddar without a second kit.

This is the only kit here that Food Network’s test kitchen named both Best Overall Cheese Making Kit and Best Hard and Soft Cheese Kit. It makes 14+ varieties including burrata, cheddar curds, Monterey Jack, chèvre, cultured butter, and ghee — enough ingredients for 20–25 gallons of milk. The liquid microbial rennet (an enzyme that curdles milk) is vegetarian and non-GMO, and it measures more easily than the tablets in most other kits.

A full 2-hour instructional video is free on the company’s YouTube channel, and the step-by-step recipes cover both fresh and aged cheeses. Buyers report the cultures and rennet work reliably, though one reviewer noted the included thermometer is basic and the curd bag is just cloth. The box arrives gift-ready, making it a thoughtful present for a serious home cook who already has a stockpot and a slotted spoon. Unlike the Cheddar Cheese-Making Kit which focuses on a single aged cheese, this kit lets you practice quick mozzarella on weeknights and then build up to something that needs weeks of patience. It does not include spices or flavorings — Standing Stone Farms removed them to keep prices down — so add your own if you want herbed chèvre or peppercorn gouda.

Check Price on Amazon

Ten cheese types and five spices in one box that can keep your kitchen producing for weeks.

This kit takes you through mozzarella, ricotta, mascarpone, halloumi, Greek-style, Scottish crowdie, labneh, goat cheese, queso blanco, and paneer — all without needing an aging fridge or a cheese cave. Each batch yields 21–32 ounces of fresh cheese, and the package includes vegetarian rennet, citric acid, organic sea salt, and five separate spices (basil, cinnamon, mint, lemon pepper, paprika) so you can flavour each batch differently. It is noticeably larger than the Fermentaholics kit at 32.0 ounces compared to 7.23 ounces — about a 4.4x gap in ingredient weight.

The three included cheese molds and the full-color recipe book are a step above the bare-bones instructions some other kits provide. One reviewer who made goat cheese and mozzarella said the learning process is straightforward, though they found the price a little high for what you get. The dry ingredients have a 1-year shelf life, so you do not have to start the morning it arrives. Unlike the Standing Stone Farms kit which uses liquid rennet, this one uses rennet tablets that need splitting, which some buyers found fiddly.

Check Price on Amazon

The one-box way to make real aged cheddar — if you can wait several months to taste it.

This 9-piece set includes a curd knife, cheesecloth, and all the ingredients for fresh cheddar: rennet, calcium chloride, cheese salt, and mesophilic culture. The kit is designed for 1-gallon batches, and one buyer mentioned doubling the first batch worked fine. Unlike the Standing Stone Farms kit which includes liquid rennet, this one packages everything you need in a box labelled for British cuisine — just add milk. The Standing Stone Farms kit makes 14+ cheese types, but the Know-How Foods kit is the only one here built purely for aged cheddar.

Here is the honest reality: cheddar needs to age. One buyer admitted they could not wait the full 9 months to get the deep flavour they wanted, and their kids kept digging into the cheese before it ever hit the aging milestone. If you enjoy the anticipation of a long-term kitchen project and want true farmhouse cheddar, this is the only kit here built for that exact goal. It does not include a cheese mold, press, or thermometer — you will need to supply those separately.

Check Price on Amazon

A dedicated chèvre kit with four molds — the narrowest focus but the best tooling for goat cheese.

If your cheesemaking goal starts and ends with creamy, tangy goat cheese, this kit skips all the distraction. It includes 4 goat cheese molds, a 5-pack of Chèvre DS culture (a specific bacterial starter for goat cheese), 1 yard of reusable butter muslin, an E4 thermometer, and a recipe booklet. The package is compact — 6 x 4 x 4 inches at 11.2 ounces, which is noticeably larger than the Mozzarella & Ricotta Kit at 4 ounces — but everything is purpose-built for chèvre.

Unlike the broader kits above, you cannot make mozzarella or cheddar from this box. But the four molds mean you can shape multiple batches at once, and the butter muslin is pre-cut and reusable. Beginners who want a single cheese to master without juggling multiple cultures will appreciate the laser focus — no rennet tablets to split, no citric acid to measure, just culture, milk, and time. No customer reviews are available in the data to validate the experience.

Check Price on Amazon

The kit that gets stretchy mozzarella on your pizza in about half an hour from pouring milk.

This 5-piece kit focuses on the two freshest, fastest cheeses: mozzarella and whole milk ricotta. It includes 5 rennet tablets, 4 ounces of citric acid, 8 ounces of cheese salt, a thermometer, and 1 yard of butter muslin. The instructions say the mozzarella takes about half an hour, which matches what several buyers reported. Compared to the Fermentaholics kit below, this one uses vegetable rennet tablets rather than microbial rennet, so it is vegetarian-friendly. At 4 ounces, it weighs about half of what Fermentaholics does (7.23 ounces), meaning you get fewer ingredient refills before you need to restock.

Buyers across the board praised the clear instructions and the high-quality, gluten-free, non-GMO ingredients. One reviewer of the Mozzarella & Ricotta Kit reported their first attempt yielded cream cheese instead of mozzarella, but the second succeeded. Common culprits for failed first batches: milk temperature too high or low, using ultra-pasteurized milk, or not dissolving rennet tablets completely.

Check Price on Amazon

Seven fresh cheeses from a single box — including burrata, which most beginner kits skip.

This 7.23-ounce kit from Fermentaholics packs 4 microbial rennet tablets, 100g of cheese salt, 100g of citric acid, a yard of grade 90 cheesecloth, and a recipe booklet called “Easin’ Into Cheesin’.” The recipes cover ricotta, mozzarella, burrata, paneer, cottage cheese, and more, and the kit works with cow, goat, sheep, or buffalo milk. One owner reported their first batch of mozzarella came out perfect, while another aimed for mozzarella but ended up with delicious burrata instead — not a failure, just a happy detour.

Note that some users found the instructions required trial and error; one customer observed they had no successful cheese using the provided instructions until doing their own research. The microbial rennet tablets are vegetarian, and the grade 90 cheesecloth is a finer weave than standard muslin, giving you a cleaner curd separation. Unlike the Cultures for Health kit which only makes mozzarella and ricotta, this one offers the widest variety of fresh cheeses from a single entry-level kit — if you are willing to learn from a small hiccup or two.

Check Price on Amazon

Twenty one-pound batches from a single kit — the cheapest way to see if cheese making sticks.

This kit from New England Cheesemaking Supply covers ricotta, mascarpone, and paneer — three acid-set cheeses that do not require rennet. Instead, it uses citric acid and tartaric acid to curdle the milk, which simplifies the process significantly. A buyer reported they successfully made delicious ricotta and planned to move on to paneer and mascarpone, also noting the kit works with a Greek yogurt maker.

The kit includes a dairy thermometer, 1 yard of reusable butter muslin, and a recipe booklet. It is the lightest and simplest option here, designed for someone who has never made cheese before and wants a low-cost test run. One reviewer called the instructions the easiest they had ever followed, and another said making the ricotta was “super easy.” Since it makes 20 one-pound batches, you get plenty of practice before needing to buy more supplies. Keep in mind you are limited to fresh, acid-set cheeses — no mozzarella stretch, no aged curds, no burrata. There is also no cheese mold or curd knife included.